Saturday, November 21, 2026

Reviewing My Own Games Without AI

 

This is a special blog post outside of my usual weekly go journal.
 
I know I am supposed to review my games on my own, before I look at AI. Clossius once suggested that when I upload a game to AI Sensei, that I turn off the AI and spend just a couple minutes clicking through the game while the AI analysis is being completed. That is simple enough, easy enough, and it makes sense to me. Have I done it more than a handful of times?  No.
 

Why have I resisted?
  • I don't know what to think about.
    But that isn't really true. I could look for occasions when I answered a move that was not sente. I could look for sub optimal moves.  I could look for my opponent's weaknesses. I could try to recall how I felt during various times in the game. I could count.

  • I am anxious to see what the AI has to say.
    I don't understand what the AI has to say half the time anyway, so why am I so anxious to see it?

  • I have enough lesson time to get all of my games reviewed, so why should I do it myself?
    It might give me things to ask in reviews with my teachers. It might provide me with more focus during my lessons. Often during a lesson it feels like I am discovering the game along with my teacher because I have forgotten what happened. 
     
I assigned myself homework.  (Actually Ben helped me to assign myself homework.) I have to review a game, and spend 15 minutes on it without AI. That might be hard. I have to come up with at least two human questions before I review with AI.  That ought to be easy.

The funny thing is that when I review a game with Ben I usually spend an hour on the lesson.  Then I spend time watching the video of the lesson while make problems for the game. That can take up to two hours.  So if I can spend three hours with that game based on my interaction with a teacher, why can't I spend fifteen minutes with the game ahead of that teacher interaction?  I would undoubtedly get value from that.
 
 
We'll see how this homework goes...
  • I spent 35 minutes on the review without AI.
  • I made 21 notes about the game while I was reviewing.
  • I did an AI review.
  • I looked at the key mistakes.
  • I figured that my 21 notes covered me for two human questions. 
 
One thing I must confess to... After I finished playing this game there was a bit of discussion with my opponent and an observer. During that discussion I took a glance at the AI for a group which the observer suggested was in danger for a good portion of time. I didn't look any further at AI because I remembered that I wasn't supposed to do that until I had reviewed the game myself.

Post game discussion of BenKyo League games is pretty inevitable. I guess I can break the rules about looking at AI as long as I don't go down the full AI rabbit hole, but limit myself to things being discussed. I suppose looking at variations dropped by observers is also okay given that they are made based on the observer's knowledge rather than AI.

I nearly forgot to mention that during this game I added a multitude of Malcovich comments. It is something that I rarely do. I asked for extra time so I could do it. We played with Fischer Time 20 minutes plus 20 seconds, and the game took 90 minutes to complete.

Do you review your games without AI ?
 


Thursday, November 19, 2026

Tsumego Hero, Show Me the Coordinates. PLEASE!

 

Sunday, November 8th
I spent a lot of time working on go problems.


Monday, November 9th
I spent five hours in the evening doing stuff I am not allowed to talk about yet.
 
 
Tuesday, November 10th
I listened to the new Star Point podcast. 

I watched two BKL players in the D-Group play a Main League game.

I participated in the Tuesday tsumego meeting. Tsumego Dragon, our preferred stie, happened to be down today.  So I offered to lead the group using Tsumego Hero.  We were all dismayed to discover that coordinates have been removed from the site for problems that you have not yet solved.  We were not amused.  We ended up having people tell me how to play directionally based on the position of my cursor hovering over the board. This actually worked much better than I could have imagined, but I am still a bit put out.  I am actually kind of angry.  What is the value of removing the coordinates?  They ruined a long standing community activity. Can't they imagine that a teacher might want to do problems with their students on Tsumego Hero? How are they to discuss them without coordinates?

Tonight is NAOL night, but my final game of the season has already been played.

I will probably observe a few games of friends who are playing at the default time. I loaded up three NAOL games at 8:00 PM and watched them. One of them had started at 7:00 pm and was in end game at the time I started to watch.
 
 
Wednesday, November 11th
I listened to the latest episode of All Things Go tonight.  I listened to the first 30 minutes of it in the car on the way to the go club.

At club I played Gayle.  I think this might have only been our second time at the club at the same time. We had our first game tonight.  Gayle suggested that we play even.  We did nigiri for color, Gayle won, and chose black.

At the beginning I was thinking that I might not be able to win the game, but I decided to give it my best effort.  I always feel behind as white, and tonight was no exception.  I eventually took the time to count, and realized that I had a comfortable margin on the board.  It was a peaceful game.  There were two points in the game when AI was nagging us both about a move.  Eventually I managed to make those moves first.  One of those situations was my need to add an extra stone at the 3-3 point in the upper right corner.  There was also a connect and die sitting on the board for a great many moves which I eventually played. The only reason I saw the move was because I stopped to count. I was also scanning the board for my next move. That move turned out to be the last move of the game, which ended in resignation.  I am looking forward to playing Gayle again. I'll be having Ben review our game from tonight soon.

 
 
Thursday, November 12th
For my lesson today Ben reviewed my most recent game with Hochul.  It didn't take the whole 90 minutes, but there was not enough time left to review another game.  I didn't want to open something that Ben would not have time to do justice to, so we spent the remainder of the time doing tsumego problems with Tsumego Dragon. I selected the Attack and Defense set of problems.


Friday, November 13th
I lead my usual Friday night tsumego group, during which we have recently been using Tsumego Hero.  Believe it or not, we actually used it, and put up with the fact that the coordinates were gone. I don't expect that to change.  They must have done it for a reason, and there are many tsumego sites to use.  Tsumego Hero's days are numbered for my Friday night tsumego group.
 
 
Saturday, November 14th
Ben taught a really good Study Group class today.  We played a game as a group.  Instead of Ben playing white's moves, every student was suggesting moves for every move of the game.  We just called out the moves, and Ben chose a move, usually based on a level of agreement by the group. It was really fun.  It was zen go at its best because we were all playing for both sides.  A good part of the class turned out to be discussing an invasion that came up.

Interestingly, Ben and I had a lesson Saturday night during which we reviewed a game with the same invasion as was played in the group class. It was a game I played a couple of weeks ago at club with Fred. I'll be sharing that lesson with the Princeton Go Club.

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Two Fun Games At Club This Week

 

Sunday, November 1st
I solved my Spaced Repetition problems, and did a little game review today.


Monday, November 2nd
I did some Attack and Defense problems on Tsumego Dragon.
 
 
Tuesday, November 3rd
I lost my NAOL game tonight by 24.5 points.  It was a disappointment.  I feel like I don't know how to play go.

The November season of BenKyo League is now active.  We have six groups this season.  Each group has six or five members per group.  What this means is that in most groups 40% of members will win one-on-one lesson time with Ben. This is not allowing for ties, which can result in even more members winning lesson time.  In October we had a three way tie for first place in one of our groups.

Now is the ideal time to join BenKyo League. When you join, please message me (buzzsaw) on Ben's discord to let me know that you have joined. Also let Ben know that buzzsaw sent you.
 
 
Wednesday, November 4th
I attended the Princeton Go Club tonight for the first time in three weeks. I listened to the All Thing Go podcast on my way to the club, getting there at 6:00  pm, playing two games, and leaving at about 9:45 pm when I finished the podcast on my way home.

My first game was with Hochul.  This was my fifth game with Hochul.  In our most recent game we had used a reverse komi equivalent to seven stones of handicap.  I had won by 5.5 so we decided to maintain the same handicap, but this time we used stones instead of reverse komi.  Hochul won this time by 4.5, so the handicap is still a good one for us.  He tells me that I have multiple opportunities to hurt his white stones, and I am sure that Ben will tell me about that.  I failed to see white's weaknesses. I felt pushed around, and it felt pretty terrible at times.  I nearly actually cried when a second harassed group seemed destined to die. I wasn't even sure how I pulled off living.  Some of the things I played may have carried more threats than I realized, or maybe Hochul saw how close I was to breaking down, and had mercy on me. There were essentially two large groups that nearly died during the game, but no more than a few random stones were actually captured.  I was simply harassed and reduced, reduced, reduced all over the board.  I don't feel so bad about a 4.5 loss. It felt good to have lost within a margin that was respectable.
 
My second game was with Fred.  This was his return to the Princeton Go Club after decades.  As we chatted during our game, we learned that our association goes way back to the early years of the new century. It was at that time that we attended multiple Yang Workshops in Gaithersburg, Maryland. I was between 18k and perhaps 13k during those years, and Fred was 1k, so we were never in the same group, and were only in the same room during the lecture segments of the workshop.  That may account for why I didn't remember his face, or it might just be my aging brain. For our game today we decided to try a two stone handicap game with me taking black.  I managed to win by 27.5 points, which surprised me.  I'll admit that it was a high to win that game. The next time we play we can try an even game and see how that goes.

I had a great night at the club.  I had a really close loss, and an unexpected sizable win that came with a walk down memory lane.

I am going to be scheduling two 60 minute Semi-Private Lesson with Ben to review these two games.

Clossius was assigned to review my NAOL game tonight.  I messaged him and told him that I would be at go club, so I could not attend live, but I would watch the video later. I asked him to drop me a link to it, which he did.
 
 
Thursday, November 5th,
I watched a BenKyo League Title Tournament game today.

Friday, November 6th
I created problems for the NAOL game that Clossius reviewed for me on Wednesday night.


Saturday, November 7th
I did 57 Attack and Defense problems in Tsumego Dragon.

I played my NAOL game for next week today at 3:00 pm.  It was a peaceful game which I won by 18.5 points.  I tried something different for this game.  I decided to make Malcovich comments.  I had plenty of time to write them since I don't really use my time.  Making the comments calmed me, and I think it helped.  When I stopped making the comments I think I started to play faster.  I counted a few times, and I was confident about the game.

Tuesday, November 03, 2026

You Should Be Watching NAOL Reviews

 

Sunday, October 25th
We had a long BKL admin meeting today.  It lasted nearly three hours.


Monday, October 26th
Oh my god! I went to do my Internet Go School problems this morning, and found that I had lost five vacation days because I was so focused on something else, and I forgot all about doing my problems.  I am down to six vacation days, and dangerously close to losing my streak altogether if I get forgetful again in the near future.
 
 
 
 
Yes.  I clicked through the 100+ problems and marked them hard without even looking at them. That's what I do.

I listened to the Star Point podcast Episode 142: Too Peaceful, No Fun.  In this episode he  mentions the famous OGS rank re-calibration of 2021.  At my level it turned out to be a five stone calibration from 12 kyu to 7 kyu.

I worked on problems for a recent game with Hochul and created 50 problems for the game. That was super fun.
 
 
Tuesday, October 27th
I played a four stone handicap game with a BenKyo League member today.  I managed to win by a small margin.  It was a fun game. My opponent played very well, and would have won if not for an error in which he played a self atari. I don't like to win that way, but a lesson was learned.

I participated in the BenKyo Study Group tsumego class today.

I won my NAOL game.
 

Wednesday, October 28th
I listened to the latest episode of All Things Go.  It is S6.13 Tang Tianyuan on Going Pro, AI Cheating Suspicions & Teaching Across Borders.

I decided not to attend go club tonight.  I watched NAOL game reviews instead.

I watched Clossius review at 7:00 PM, and I watched Ben review at 9:00 PM.

Ben was in the middle of reviewing my game when someone ended the session for everyone.  Ben needed to finish the review offline.  I'll be able to see the rest of it when it gets published.  The guy who starts reviewing at 10:00 PM is going to have to be told that Ben routinely puts in overtime and that the session should not be ended for everyone.  While you may not be participating in NAOL as a player, you can watch the NAOL reviews after the fact.  Reviews are recorded, and the videos are published weekly in a blog post on the USGO website.
 
You will find the NAOL Review Blog in the 4th row of blogs immediately below my own blog.
 
 
Thursday, October 29th
I spent four hours tonight working on stuff I can't talk about yet.


Friday, October 30th
I spent a good deal of time creating problems for some of my recent games.  One of them was the NAOL game that Ben reviewed for me Wednesday night.


Saturday, October 31st
I spent more time creating problems today.

Today is the last day of the October season of BenKyo League.  I watched a league member get in two games in a row for the league today.  I watched two other last minute league games as well.  I love seeing the end-of-season flurry of activity. For me, today was about watching rather than doing. Tomorrow starts our three day transitional period between seasons for BenKyo League.  The next season of BKL starts late in the day on November 3rd.

There is no better time to join Benkyo League.  If you join please tell Ben that buzzsaw sent you.

 

 

Monday, October 26, 2026

I Blundered in My NAOL Game

I didn't go into a lot of detail this week, and there are no images either, so this was really easy to post.

 

Sunday, October 18th
I spent a great deal of time today solving problems created for my recent games.  
 

Monday, October 19th
I didn't sleep well last night so I am taking a rest day.
I listened to the latest episode of Star Point.


Tuesday, October 20th
I lost my NAOL game tonight.  I was ahead, and it was almost over, and then something bad happened.  I made a mistake and I suffered because of it. I lost the game by 14.5 points. I'll have Clossius look at it on Friday.


Wednesday, October 21st
I didn't go to club tonight, but I did listen to the latest episode of All things Go.  It was a brief episode.  It was the final episode of a series for beginners. After finishing it though, I saw that there was another episode, Go's Enduring Appeal,  to listen to, and so I did.


Thursday, October 22nd
In my lesson with Ben today we reviewed a game I played with Parker last week at the Princeton Go Club. We spent the full 90 minutes on that one game.


Friday, October 23rd
I had a lesson with Clossius during which he reviewed five of my recent games. Two of them were NAOL games.


Saturday, October 24th
I watched Ben's Group Class live about reviewing your own games.  It is the second in a series.
 

Wednesday, October 21, 2026

What Happens at Club Doesn't Necessarily Stay at Club

 

Sunday, October 11th
We had a long administrative meeting for BenKyo League today.
 

Monday, October 12th
A game I played five and a half years ago ended up being drawn to my attention last Saturday.  I managed to find it, and noticed that, in the chat of the game, I mentioned that it might get reviewed the next day because I was starting lessons with Clossius. 

Anyone who wants to view the game can see it here.
 
I decided to take a look at my first lesson with Clossius, which you can find here. It was live streamed. The game I played the day before did not get reviewed.  It turned out that Clossius was more interested in reviewing something else. Viewing this lesson was a major walk down memory lane for me. I have been taking lessons with Clossius now for five and a half years.
 
This was the first time I had a lesson on Twitch so there was some misunderstanding at the beginning about the fact that I needed to mute the Twitch Stream.  You can skip over all of that. There is mention of my involvement with the American Yunguseng Dojang, which I continued with from 2019 to 2024. I did five years of AYD. Clossius mentions that he has me as 12k on OGS, but that was before the famous rank adjustments.  The adjustment put me to 7k. That was a five stone increase in rank for me, and it is shown retroactively in all games from before the adjustment.  During this lesson Clossius reviews a game I played on KGS with one of my 6k accounts. My OGS account was 7k.
 
This lesson was exactly one year to the day before I started lessons with BenKyo Baduk.  My lesson anniversary with both of my current teachers is January 13th.

Today I listened to the newest episode of Star Point.  The title of the episode is 140: Honing Your Go Sense.
 

Tuesday, October 13th
I participated in the BenKyo League tsumego class.

I won my first NAOL game of the 24th season by 0.5

I played three games on Fox tonight using Better Baduk as a playing interface.  It worked really well.  I might end up giving up my subscription to Parallels Desktop since the only reason I subscribe is so I can play on Fox.
 
 
Wednesday, October 14th
I listened to the new episode on All Things Go tonight.  I listened to about thirty minutes of it on my way to the Princeton Go club. 

I played Parker who had to take 104.5 points of reverse komi this time. That is his own fault because he keeps winning. Tonight his winning streak came to an end. I won the game by 21.5 points, and Parker will be back to 91.5 points of reverse Komi next time. Hopefully I can chip away at that over time.

I then watched Andy and Parker play a game. They used a clock with no main time and five periods of 30 seconds byo yomi.  I told them that this information was going into the blog, and I joked that if something happens at the club it may end up in the blog.

There was some discussion tonight about the video of the lesson I had with Ben last Thursday, which I posted to the club Discord server.  Andy brought up the fact that Ben had likened strategy in go to holding cards in Magic The Gathering.  Parker has not watched that video yet, but was interested in doing so.  I am going to be listening to the video again soon to create go problems from the reviews of the two games that Ben and I covered in that lesson, so I will pay particular attention to the references to Magic The Gathering when they comes up.

I listened to more of the All Things Go podcast on my way home from the Princeton Go club, and I am finishing up the rest of it at home right now.  I think that listening to the All Things Go podcast going to and from the club is going to become a weekly tradition.  It makes sense that I do it with All Things Go rather than Star Point because Travis, the creator of All Things Go, is actually a member of the Princeton Go Club.
 
 
Thursday, October 15th
Tonight a few of the Princeton Go Club members watched Parker play his NAOL game.  I was able to participate in that because the game was at a time other than the default playing time.  A few of us gathered in the voice channel on the Princeton Go Club Discord, and commented on the game as it took place.  Parker was doing great, and then he made a mistake that turned the game.  I felt his pain. We all felt his pain.  Discussion continued post game.
 

Friday, October 16th 
Members of the Princeton Go Club gathered again on Discord to watch the NAOL game of Andy.  Discussion continued after the game, but I needed to leave for my 8:00 pm scheduled activitiy. I proceeded to lead my tsumego group.
 

Saturday, October 17th
I worked on a lot of stuff I can't talk about yet.

Monday, October 12, 2026

2700 Days in a Row

Most of my post this week is dedicated to my weekly visit at the Princeton Go Club. 

 

Sunday, October 4th
I logged into the Awesome Baduk discord and noticed a video for Bent Four in the Corner for the 10k to 15k level, and I watched it.


Monday, October 5th
I hit a new benchmark at The Internet Go School, I have completed 2,700 days in a row.  Well, not literally in a row. You earn vacation days, and if you miss a day, and have a vacation day to use, you keep your streak. On the day I hit 2700 days in a row I had nine vacation days left.
 
 

 
I spent a good deal of time reviewing games today.

Tuesday, October 6th,
I listened to the new Star Point podcast and the new All Things Go podcast. I should probably save one or the other of these podcasts for later in the week to spread out the go podcast goodness a little bit.  I'll have to think about this.

I attended the BKL tsumego group.

More Level 2 problems in Tsumego Dragon
  • 33 Loop/Ko

I spent a good deal of time working on go problems created from a recent lesson with Ben.
 
 
Wednesday, October 7th
I attended the Princeton Go Club tonight which made me really happy because I was unable to go last week. I played two games, and had a great time.  Winning both of the games was a plus, but I think I would have been equally happy if the games had gone in the opposite direction by the same margin. Both of the games had very small margins. These are the types of games I like. The games where I die big, or simply lose by huge margins from bleeding point, are both demoralizing, but I think I am taking them well. When I lose by fewer than ten points I feel as if I played well, but a little less efficiently than I should have.

The first game of the evening was with Hochul.  We played a game with 78.5 points of reverse komi. We based the level of komi on the results of three games we played one night in quick succession. That was well over a month ago, so it was definitely time for us to play again.  All three of those games were five stone handicap games. The first two games ended in early resignations by me after something died. Ben told me, when he reviewed those games, that both of those resignations were premature. Hochul and I got the last game to go to scoring in an attempt to get a handle on what a proper handicap ought to be. It ended up being a fairly decisive victory for Hochul. We decided that, as a result, a seven stone negative komi equivalent would make sense.  I won our game tonight by 5.5, which makes us believe that we have found a good handicap.

Here is our game on Better Baduk.
 
 
 
The second game was with Andy.  We had played three times previously, and have not yet zeroed in on a proper handicap.  Our most recent game was three stones, but had been quite a while ago, so we decided to try three stones again.  I asked Andy to choose between reverse komi and stones.  He chose stones. We had a very close game, but I squeaked out a victory.  So it appears as if three stones is a good handicap.  I've won twice at three stones, and I think that we probably ought to observe a three-game kadoban with rank changing after three consecutive wins for one player or the other.  I was disappointed in my recording skills in this game because I messed something up on the game record and had to abandon recording very near the end of the game

I found out later that I had accidentally given white 7.5 points of komi when I set up the game.  I later fixed the metadata to reflect the correct komi.  Better Baduk gave me this message when I did that.
 
 

 
Here is our game on Better Baduk. This link reflects what the AI estimates the score to be when I stopped recording with the corrected komi.
 
 
 
Hochul was kind enough to fill in the extra stones on the board to replicate the final board position.  I took a screen capture of that, and here it is. (However, this result still reflects the 7.5 komi error.) So it is probably actually B+ 10.5 
 

 
Andy brings out the best in me according to Better Baduk's estimate of my rank in the game with him compared to my rank in the game with Hochul.

Against Andy, I am 5 dan.
 
 

 
 
Compare that to the Better Baduk estimate of my rank based on the Hochul game, where I am 8 kyu.
 

 
 
Thursday, October 8th
I started my day with spaced repetition problems on The Internet Go School.  I lost another vacation day earlier this week, but it is what it is.  I just have to be better about remembering to do my problems.  Today I came upon an easy problem and had to laugh because I will surely be dead when it will come around again.  I will be well over 100 years old in 34 years.  
 
 

 
 
BTW, this is not a one move problem, but it was super easy.

I had a lesson with Ben today. We reviewed the two games I played last night at The Princeton Go Club where I will share the reviews.
 

Friday, October 9th
I again spent a good deal of time working on creating go problems.

I lead my usual tsumego group tonight.  We used Tsumego Hero.
 
 
Saturday, October 10th
I attended Ben's Study Group Class today.  The subject of the class was reviewing your own games. It was a great class.  One of the things Ben recommended is to review the game without AI first and, assuming you are using OGS, drop a variation for every move you feel is questionable, or that you want to follow up on.  I tend to be guilty of not reviewing my games myself. I depend on my teachers to review them. I have a lot of lesson time to spend, and relatively few games to review, so it is easy to get them all reviewed by my teachers.  Ben's class today convinced me, however, that I will get more from my lessons if I review my games on my own ahead of time.  I've already noticed that when I have bothered to click through recent games before a lesson, I get more from the lesson. When asked for alternative moves I am more likely to come up with good ones, and the game feels more fresh.