Saturday, November 21, 2026

Reviewing My Own Games Without AI

 

This is a special blog post outside of my usual weekly go journal.
 
I know I am supposed to review my games on my own, before I look at AI. Clossius once suggested that when I upload a game to AI Sensei, that I turn off the AI and spend just a couple minutes clicking through the game while the AI analysis is being completed. That is simple enough, easy enough, and it makes sense to me. Have I done it more than a handful of times?  No.
 

Why have I resisted?
  • I don't know what to think about.
    But that isn't really true. I could look for occasions when I answered a move that was not sente. I could look for sub optimal moves.  I could look for my opponent's weaknesses. I could try to recall how I felt during various times in the game. I could count.

  • I am anxious to see what the AI has to say.
    I don't understand what the AI has to say half the time anyway, so why am I so anxious to see it.

  • I have enough lesson time to get all of my games reviewed, so why should I do it myself?
    It might give me things to ask in reviews with my teachers. It might provide me with more focus during my lessons. Often during a lesson it feels like I am discovering the game along with my teacher because I have forgotten what happened. 
     
I assigned myself homework.  (Actually Ben helped me to assign myself homework.) I have to review a game, and spend 15 minutes on it without AI. That might be hard. I have to come up with at least two human questions before I review with AI.  That ought to be easy.

The funny thing is that when I review a game with Ben I usually spend an hour on the lesson.  Then I spent time watching the video of the lesson while make problems for the game. That can take up to two hours.  So if I can spend three hours with that game based on my interaction with a teacher, why can't I spend fifteen minutes with the game ahead of that teacher interaction?  I would undoubtedly get value from that.
 
 
We'll see how this homework goes...
  • I spent 35 minutes on the review without AI.
  • I made 21 notes about the game while I was reviewing.
  • I did an AI review.
  • I looked at the key mistakes.
  • I figured that my 21 notes covered me for two human questions. 
 
One thing I must confess to... After I finished playing this game there was a bit of discussion with my opponent and an observer. During that discussion I took a glance at the AI for a group which the observer suggested was in danger for a good portion of time. I didn't look any further at AI because I remembered that I wasn't supposed to do that until I had reviewed the game myself.

Post game discussion of BenKyo League games is pretty inevitable. I guess I can break the rules about looking at AI as long as I don't go down the full AI rabbit hole, but limit myself to things being discussed. I suppose looking at variations dropped by observers is also okay given that they are made based on the observers knowledge rather than AI.

I nearly forgot to mention that during this game I added a multitude of Malcovich comments. It is something that I rarely do. I asked for extra time so I could do it. We played with Fischer Time 20 minutes plus 20 seconds, and the game took 90 minutes to complete.

Do you review your games without AI ?
 


No comments: